NJ ANCHOR Support★ out of 5 stars Real Estate Agents
Your Watchdog

My dashboard
Check ANCHOR and Stay NJ How NJ appeals work
See homes on this block

509 Prospect Street

Nutley Township, NJ · Essex County · Residential · Block 4903, Lot 12

Watchdog Score

How it works
66/100

Favorable tax position

The Watchdog Score, powered by the ROBUST Framework. Evidence coverage 55%, low confidence.

  • RRecourse55
  • OOverassessment Positionn/a
  • BBurden61
  • UUniformity85
  • SStabilityn/a
  • TTrajectoryn/a

Property tax

Compare towns
$12,7132024 tax bill
$13,0362025 at new rate
$483,000Assessed value
$12,338Nutley Township median
$2.6992025 rate

Among 8,196 homes in Nutley Township, the typical (median) tax bill is $12,338. This bill is higher than about 56% of them.

Town tax rate per $100
  • 23
  • 24
  • 25

Rates start in 2023, the first year after the last town-wide revaluation.

Sales

Nearby sales
$182,500 on December 18, 1998This property's last sale
335Similar sales since 2023
$625,000Median price

Is this your home?

Claim it to follow its assessment, tax and score in your Watchdog account. Once ownership is verified, you can add a photo that shows wherever this address appears on Watchdog.

Claim this home Add a photo

Recent sales nearby

AddressSoldPriceBuilt
479 Prospect StreetSame streetJul 2024$836,0001900
357 Prospect StreetSame streetJul 2024$999,9992006
303 Prospect StreetSame streetNov 2024$478,2001939
316 Prospect StreetSame streetJan 2024$600,0001860
73 Prospect StreetSame streetJun 2024$750,0001921
247 Vreeland AvenueJan 2024$852,0001906

Same property type in the same town, same street first. Prices come from the state tax list, which runs about a year behind, and can include sales between relatives or other non-market transfers.

Homeowner tools

  • Could an appeal lower this bill?The appeal estimator opens with this property's assessment and the town tax rate filled in.
  • Appeal deadlinesUsually April 1 (May 1 after a town-wide revaluation), or 45 days after assessment notices go out if later.
  • ANCHOR, Senior Freeze and Stay NJCheck which state property tax relief programs apply.
  • Buying here?Monthly cost with the real tax bill included.
  • Selling? CO requirementsResale certificate of occupancy and smoke detector certificate rules for Nutley Township.
  • Nutley Township property taxesTypical bill, tax rate and appeal deadline for the town.
  • MapOpen this address in Google Maps.

Property record

Block / lot
4903 / 12
Property class
Residential (2)
Year built
1920
Dwelling units
1
Land value
$246,000
Improvement value
$237,000
County
Essex County

Same block

  • 259 Vreeland Avenue$21,803 tax
  • 519 Prospect Street$14,268 tax
  • 515 Prospect Street$13,163 tax
  • 14 Coeyman Avenue$20,961 tax
  • 24 Coeyman Avenue$14,584 tax
  • 32 Coeyman Avenue$15,745 tax
  • 40 Coeyman Avenue$12,428 tax
  • 44 Coeyman Avenue$16,026 tax

Get alerts for this property

We check the state tax list once a month and email you if the assessment, tax bill or Watchdog Score for 509 Prospect Street changes. Unsubscribe any time.

Property report (PDF)

A printable report for 509 Prospect Street: tax and assessment, the Watchdog Score, how the bill compares in Nutley Township, recent nearby sales and appeal dates.

Share

TextEmailFacebookXLinkedIn

Questions

How much are the property taxes at 509 Prospect Street?

The latest annual property tax on the New Jersey tax list is $12,713, on an assessed value of $483,000.

How does this tax bill compare with others in Nutley Township?

Among 8,196 homes in Nutley Township, the typical (median) tax bill is $12,338. This bill is higher than about 56% of them.

What is the Watchdog Score?

The Watchdog Score, powered by the ROBUST Framework, rates a property's tax position from 0 to 100 using six kinds of public evidence. Higher is better. This property scores 66 (Favorable tax position).

Can the assessment be appealed?

Yes. Appeals go to the Essex County Board of Taxation. In most towns the deadline is April 1 (May 1 after a town-wide revaluation), or 45 days after assessment notices are mailed if that is later.

Does Watchdog show who owns this property?

No. Watchdog does not show owner names or mailing addresses. Everything on this page comes from public tax and parcel records.

Source: New Jersey MOD-IV tax list and NJ Office of GIS parcel data, refreshed monthly (last refresh October 2026). Town tax rates from the NJ Division of Taxation. Watchdog does not show owner names. How we get our numbers

Photo by Zac Gudakov on Unsplash
Privacy Terms Contact