New Milford Borough, NJ · Bergen County · Residential · Block 1704, Lot 17
Favorable tax position
The Watchdog Score, powered by the ROBUST Framework. Evidence coverage 55%, low confidence.
Among 4,125 homes in New Milford Borough, the typical (median) tax bill is $12,605. This bill is close to the middle.
Rates start in 2025, the first year after the last town-wide revaluation.
Claim it to follow its assessment, tax and score in your Watchdog account. Once ownership is verified, you can add a photo that shows wherever this address appears on Watchdog.
| Address | Sold | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 375 Shea DrSame street | Jan 2024 | $741,000 |
| 343 Shea DrSame street | Jul 2024 | $750,000 |
| 311 Shea DrSame street | Oct 2024 | $800,000 |
| 322 Shea DrSame street | Nov 2024 | $625,000 |
| 374 Lacey Dr | Nov 2023 | $600,000 |
| 147 Hirschfeld Pl | Nov 2023 | $799,000 |
Same property type in the same town, same street first. Prices come from the state tax list, which runs about a year behind, and can include sales between relatives or other non-market transfers.
We check the state tax list once a month and email you if the assessment, tax bill or Watchdog Score for 371 Shea Dr changes. Unsubscribe any time.
A printable report for 371 Shea Dr: tax and assessment, the Watchdog Score, how the bill compares in New Milford Borough, recent nearby sales and appeal dates.
The latest annual property tax on the New Jersey tax list is $12,634, on an assessed value of $671,700.
Among 4,125 homes in New Milford Borough, the typical (median) tax bill is $12,605. This bill is close to the middle.
The Watchdog Score, powered by the ROBUST Framework, rates a property's tax position from 0 to 100 using six kinds of public evidence. Higher is better. This property scores 79 (Favorable tax position).
Yes. Appeals go to the Bergen County Board of Taxation. In most towns the deadline is April 1 (May 1 after a town-wide revaluation), or 45 days after assessment notices are mailed if that is later.
No. Watchdog does not show owner names or mailing addresses. Everything on this page comes from public tax and parcel records.
Source: New Jersey MOD-IV tax list and NJ Office of GIS parcel data, refreshed monthly (last refresh October 2026). Town tax rates from the NJ Division of Taxation. Watchdog does not show owner names. How we get our numbers